When it comes to renting out a property, landlords often rely heavily on credit scores to assess potential tenants. While a good credit score can indicate financial responsibility, it doesn’t always paint the full picture of someone’s qualities as a renter. In fact, many excellent tenants may not have perfect credit but still possess traits that make them highly desirable. Here are the top 10 signs of a great renter—beyond the numbers.

1. Consistent Employment and Income

Steady employment with a verifiable income shows a renter has the financial means to pay rent regularly. Pay stubs, employment verification, or proof of consistent freelance income can speak volumes, even if the tenant’s credit isn’t ideal.

2. Strong References from Previous Landlords

A glowing reference from a previous landlord is one of the most reliable indicators of a great renter. If someone consistently paid rent on time, respected the property, and followed lease terms in the past, it’s likely they’ll do the same again.

3. Punctual Communication

Tenants who respond to emails, calls, and texts in a timely and respectful manner demonstrate responsibility and professionalism. This is especially important when addressing maintenance issues or updates from the landlord.

4. Respect for the Property

Great renters treat the property like it’s their own. They keep it clean, avoid damage, and notify the landlord of any needed repairs early. A tidy appearance during a property viewing can be a subtle hint of how they’ll treat the space once they move in.

Discover: 10 Ways to Save Money on Home Maintenance

5. Long-Term Intentions

While not always a requirement, renters who express interest in staying long-term can reduce the stress and cost of frequent tenant turnover. Stability is appealing to landlords and suggests the renter is serious about maintaining a good rental relationship.

Read more: The Secrets to Happy Long-Term Tenants

6. Prepared and Organized

Great tenants often come to showings or interviews prepared with all necessary documents—ID, proof of income, references, and more. Being organized indicates a responsible mindset and makes the rental process smoother.

7. Polite and Respectful Demeanor

Courtesy goes a long way. A respectful and considerate attitude during property visits and conversations suggests the renter will also be cooperative when issues arise and respectful to neighbors.

8. Low Maintenance Requests

Some tenants frequently demand upgrades or excessive attention to minor issues. A great renter understands the difference between necessary repairs and cosmetic preferences, helping maintain a reasonable landlord-tenant relationship.

9. Good Rental History

Even without stellar credit, a solid rental history—especially with no evictions or disputes—can provide confidence to landlords. A track record of on-time payments and adherence to lease terms shows reliability.

10. Responsible Lifestyle

Finally, great renters show they live responsibly. Whether it’s not having loud parties, taking care of pets, or ensuring trash and common areas are kept clean, their actions reflect maturity and consideration for others.

Conclusion

While credit scores offer useful financial insight, they shouldn’t be the only factor in evaluating a renter. Traits like communication, respect, organization, and a stable rental history can be even more valuable. For landlords, recognizing these qualities can lead to more positive rental experiences and lasting tenant relationships.